Skip to main content

Some Thoughts on Dinah

Shimon and Levi were punishing the perpertrators and enablers of Dinah's abuse for her sake as an individual person, not because she "belonged" to the family - as is sometimes suggested. I would point to a subtle point in the syntax of the text. But throughout all of the Torah many things are taught to us with that subtlety of the classic exegesis. Often, when a sibling is described it says the "sister of X was Y" making the "sister(Y)" subordinate to the "X" as in our Parsha, later, "ואחות לוטן תמנע" But here, we it is written "אשר טמא דינה אחותם" that Shimon and Levi used deception and violence because Shechem defiled "Dinah their sister" the name first. Dinah as a person first then the relationship. It was the harm and abuse to Dinah that primarily drove them. Nachmanides explained that they slew the men of Shechem because they stood by and did not stop the attack on Dinah. Those who do not stop an evil, are partners in said evil. At any rate, it is clearly the person Dinah as an individual who they care about, and this is subordinate to the "clan" aspect. Also, it says earlier that they were "aggrieved because this is ought not to be done to a daughter of Jacob". In the Middle East and much of the world to this day in such a case as Dinah's - either they kill the victim or make her marry the criminal and the girl's father takes some money as compensation. However, from way back when, "this is not the way a daughter of Jacob is treated". Our family sees the matriarchs and daughters as partners - as Human Beings with agency. Jacob does not leave his father in law until he consults with his wives who declare that (in paraphrase) "we are going with you, our father treated us as property whereas here we are partners". This is very clear from last week's portion and this week's if you read the text carefully and compare it with the societies in which the Patriarchs lived and whose bad habits continue in far too many societies to this day. Also, we should point out that the Lubavitcher Rebbe understands her "going out" and the comparison with Leah her mother in a positive light. He understands the the midrash to mean that Dinah sought to influence the daughters of the land in a positive way as her great grandparents Abraham and Sarah did. Another midrash explicitly states that Abraham sought to influence the men to monotheism and Sarah sought to influence the women. Reaching out to other women is certainly something that is seen as a positive thing in the Biblical context. In this case because of the corruption and misogyny of the city of Shechem bad things happened. We nevertheless can understand the text - both biblical and rabbinic- as praising Dinah, not criticizing her. As I began this note if we read things carefully and are willing to transcend preconceived notions they tell a very different story. One can argue that theShechem episode is the very first successful protest on behalf of women's rights, albeit by allies.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Some thoughts on the death of an arch-terrorist

For all of us who were old enough to understand what those terrible towering billows of smoke drifting from lower Manhattan to Brooklyn, visible from as far away as Connecticut, and worldwide electronically meant on 9/11, the death of Osama bin Laden cannot but strike a chord in that place in our hearts that seek to see revealed justice in this world. After all one of the basic tenets of the Noahide the universal law of humanity is - “Shofech dam hadam beadam damo yishafeych” He who spills the blood of man, his blood shall be spilled”. Yet we understand that this is not out of a Divine concession to a desire for revenge, vengeful feelings are unworthy of human being (kedoshim). Rather we grasp that there is no place in the world for a person who does not respect the image of G-d that is each one of us. The murderer all the more so the cold blooded ideological murderer says: “I decide the value of a human being”. This is a more direct denial of g-d than even Idol worship, which simply...

In Those Days at This Time - Chanukah Redux

  Our Chanukah Message, and for this year, and an announcement of new classes at Bnai Torah Boruch Hashem! “In those days at this time” So goes the Refrain of Al Hanisim – the additional prayer we add to the Amidah and the Grace after Meals During Chanukah and Purim. Chanukah is about the attempt to destroy Judaism and co-opt the Jews of the Land of Israel into the idolatrous, immoral, hedonistic and polytheistic Hellenist world. Our enemies, the Seleucids -with an empire centered in Syria, sought to use both the blandishments of societal acceptance and when that failed, force of arms and persecution to coerce us towards this goal. They desired that we bow to the prevailing values and beliefs held by the whole world -except for us Jews. In effect they said: “How can it be that you have the Chutzpah to believe the whole world is wrong and you are right?”. We responded that – “This is indeed the case, which is why empires, kingdoms, values and beliefs come and go, but our nation, ou...

Baseball and Elul

  As we enter the fall, and prepare for Tishrei – The High Holidays, Sukkot and Simchat Torah, we are also poised at a key moment of the great American sport - the climactic crescendo of the Baseball season. True, in the grand scheme of things this may seem trivial, yet - all happens by Divine Providence. As a result of this reality, Rabbi Israel Ba’al Shem Tov taught “Everything we hear and see must teach us a means of enhancing our Divine work”. Since this sporting milestones are always close to this most intense period of the Judaic year, they must teach us something important. One of the special characteristics of baseball is the need for thorough preparation outside the games themselves. The perfect strike, the brilliant at-bat, the towering homer, the gravity-defying leaping catch at the wall, the perfectly choreographed double (or triple!) play all are the products of intense preparation and practice over many hours, days, months, and years. The necessary development of th...